Content Page

No data
thumbnail

Unbiased Performance Management:
The Edge of ONA Over Traditional Methods

An abstract background showing a network with green lines and dots.
user-avatar
Hacking HR Team
icon-calendar

Posted on February 08, 2024

Once a year, like clockwork, performance reviews loom - sending pulses racing and morale plummeting. Both sides believe these mandated meetings deliver helpful feedback or fair ratings. With a low percentage of employees finding reviews inspirational, why do many companies- stubbornly stick to a broken system? 

The culprit is a widening fissure between how we rate contributions versus how collaborative work occurs today. Annual evaluations centered on individual outputs misrepresent ecosystems where fluid teams drive outcomes. Static forms struggle to capture complex dynamics like influence, problem-solving, or mentorship. And manager bias distorts rating accuracy.

But what if technology helped rewrite rules built for yesterday? People analytics introduces an innovative methodology for viewing performance through a new lens - interactions. Organizational Network Analysis (ONA) maps connections to reveal the collective impact hidden from conventional reviews. Could this disruptor realize the intent behind exhausting evaluations - fueled growth rather than perfunctory judgment?

9 Innovative Ways ONA Transforms Performance Reviews

The quest to reinvent performance evaluations continues as priorities shift in a disrupted world. Despite tech-fueled transformations across enterprises, antiquated reviews linger - reduced to an annual exercise in frustration. Even innovative approaches like continuous feedback and crowdsourced ratings overlook the connected nature of work. 

As organizations evolve into multifaceted ecosystems, the need for data illuminating collective accomplishments grows as organizations evolve into multi-dimensional ecosystems. Cue the promise of Organizational Network Analysis (ONA) - finally adding a missing, metrics-powered lens to decode complexity. By quantifying collaboration, problem-solving, and interdependence patterns, ONA transcends bias to spotlight value creation.

The methodology’s innate agility moves beyond evaluating fixed roles. Dynamic network maps reveal the tangible impact of standout team players and mentors who amplify innovation. ONA-powered insights guide leaders to nurture talent, foster engagement, and configure high-performing teams primed for the challenges ahead. As we explore nine game-changing ways ONA upgrades reviews, what possibilities excite you about this modern approach? What questions or concerns remain about its real-world application?

1. Enhanced Objectivity

ONA counteracts subjective biases that distort conventional evaluations by tracking real-world collaboration and output data across the organization. This unfiltered bird's-eye visibility surfaces hidden gems who drive critical outcomes but get overlooked in biased manager ratings or time-crunched peer surveys. However, even analytics has limitations in capturing the full spectrum of human potential and interpersonal nuance. Can metrics quantify the inspiration of an ingenious idea that reframes the problem? Do maps trace how a seasoned leader grooms protégés through patient counsel rather than key performance indicators? The quest for objectivity must balance data-driven insight with human-centric wisdom.

2. Uncovering Hidden Talents

Typical reviews often overlook silent contributors who amplify team success through mentorship, coordination across silos, or morale building because such platform building goes unseen. ONA redresses this by illuminating connectors who share knowledge, facilitate cohesion, and energize colleagues but rarely receive recognition. However, pendulums also risk swinging from undervaluing collaboration to over-celebrating indirect support at the cost of outcomes. How can evaluation frameworks evolve to RIGHT-size the weightage of individual brilliance and collaborative multiplier effects based on context?

3. Real-Time Feedback 

Annual appraisals struggle to capture dynamic role evolution and quarterly goalposts quickening in volatile times. It fuels perception gaps between managers pressed for time and employees seeking activation. ONA addresses lag issues by offering hourly nudges on collaboration friction points, silo risks, and changemaker trends based on interaction shifts. But always-on stimulus also carries downsides like tunnel vision on activities rather than purpose. In the quest to course-correct continually, how might you maintain sight of the big picture of the human need for meaning?

4. Team Dynamics Analysis

Typical assessments need clarification on interdependent workflows and help distill individual contributions from the collective output. ONA parses cross-functional collaboration by mapping knowledge flows, trust clusters, and resource coordination hubs that quantify the health of team alignment. But solely mapping digital communications has inherent gaps in tracing systemic blocks or personality clashes stymieing harmony. Surveys confirm time invested in conflict resolution and psychological safety directly uplifts team performance. So, while tracking workflow connections is indispensable, holistic health requires blending digital and emotional signals within groups. How might leadership balance task-driven number crunching with fostering connections between people?

5. Improved Employee Engagement 

Disengaged employees cost companies over $8.8 trillion annually in lost productivity. Alarmingly, only around 23% remain energized by their work. ONA diagnostics can pinpoint at-risk talent showing signs of isolation or burnout through dashboard nudges early for tailored interventions—similarly, analytics aids in targeting learning to activate overlooked innovators. However, boil-the-ocean analytics still struggles to replace the insight of savvy managers into what makes individual employees tick. Can evaluations move from depersonalized data-informed diagnosis toward humanized solutions activated through personal understanding, empathy, and trust?

6. Strategic Talent Management

Business strategy pressures HR to predict capability gaps, tailor learning, and proactively upskill critical workforce segments as competitive forces reshape demands. ONA enriches foresight by uncovering skill adjacencies primed for development, pockets of expertise to leverage through lateral transfers, and cross-training and mentorship hubs to amplify knowledge sharing. But analytics is just a compass, not the journey itself. The path to building future-ready capabilities still depends on inspired individuals driving grassroots transformation through relationships that spur creative growth often invisible to dashboards restricted to counting competencies. How might you harness analytical horsepower while still nurturing the human spirit of learning?

7. Cultural Insight  

Culture remains a crucial differentiator that 94% of executives prioritize, and 88% of employees believe a distinct workplace culture is essential to business success. Tracking interaction shifts via ONA offers vital signals into evolving org DNA - what behaviors drive promotions, which collaborations shape decisions, and whether rhetoric aligns with reality. But while data pattern analysis provides diagnostic direction, actualizing aspirational values requires leadership courage combined with humility. Turning the mirror onto internal dysfunctions calls for resilient dialogues, not just diagnosing dissonance. How might analytics expand from sterile reporting into courageous conversations to shape cultural realignment? 

8. Data-Informed Decision-Making

In matrixed organizations, leaders often rely on biased hypotheses or inefficient workarounds to direct strategy and operations. ONA simulation models empower more objective scenario planning by stress-testing proposals based on past successes, gaps, and team readiness. However, the promise of decisiveness through analytics still warrants prudence. Numbers should direct stakeholders, not replace co-created solutions. What guardrails around transparency, ethics, and accountability will guide deployment as predictive analytics matures from promise to practice? 

9. Bias Reduction

Psychology confirms cognitive biases distort decision-making. Confirmation bias leads managers to seek to validate evidence, while similarity bias primes overvaluing people like them. Reviews facing time poverty magnify such prejudices that non-performance factors sway 60% of ratings. ONA counters bias by spotlighting measurable, collaborative impact beyond fixed perceptions. But when organizational values demand balancing multiple bottom lines spanning people, profit, and community, is performance analytics enough without other ethical lenses? Can data broaden yet not dehumanize how you evaluate human capital?

ONA breakthroughs performance ceilings by introducing an interaction analytics lens, revealing blindspots, energizing talent, and optimizing decisions. The methodology charts an objective path to reimagining evaluations as catalysts accelerating individual and organizational success. However, embracing possibilities also warrants preparation if this disruptive innovation aims to become an enterprise-wide movement rather than a siloed experiment. So, what bridges promise to practice? The pivot lies in six indispensable elements for impactful adoption. Aligning strategy, executive sponsorship, change management, skill building, technological integration, and embedding ONA into cultural DNA – together, these critical factors uplift and amplify results.

6 Critical Factors for Effective ONA Implementation

Transitioning to ONA warrants progress beyond piecemeal tools tacked onto redundant frameworks straining under modern demands. Realizing potential calls for the reimagination of an enabled human-centric architecture - unified, responsive, and continually learning. 

This seismic shift starts by transforming fixed mindsets, clinging to the status quo even as frustrations mount. Leadership courage must light the path, casting vision and investing resources to elevate capacity. Workforce reskilling and reorganized cross-functional teams set the stage for technology to amplify, not replace, collective wisdom.

Sustaining transformation demands empathy, inquiry, and transparency as cornerstones. Holistic adoption unlocks ONA's total value but requires integrating the innovation within – not on top of – talent processes, decision rights, and knowledge flows already onboard. What undercurrents might accelerate versus obstruct this culture reset aiming to upgrade how organizations evaluate performance?

1. Data Integrity

Centralizing relevant digital exhaust from collaboration tools with context from business goals enriches network models, revealing mission-critical insights. But balancing transparency with security during roll-out is critical to building trust in data collection and usage. How might we reassure skittish colleagues of ethical practices safeguarding consent?

2. User-Friendly Tools

Accessible visual interfaces empower workforce navigation of ONA's complex systemic interconnections influencing decision-making. However, positioning powerful analytics as simplifying rather than intimidating remains vital for mainstream adoption across business and support functions. How might we foster digital confidence and curiosity and not overwhelm users with fancy tools?

3. Stakeholder Buy-in 

Winning over historically ignored talent segments transforms ONA’s disruptive theory into inclusive practice. Structured listening and co-creation from diverse voices are indispensable to surface real needs before designing "solutions." How might we move from ready-fire-aim technology launches towards patient dialogue uncovering mutual benefit?

4. Training and Development

Investments in upskilling analytics literacy allow the broader organization to unlock intelligence from data democratization. However, the focus must expand beyond capability building to nurture willingness framed by a purpose more significant than any tool. How might internal mobility pathways inspire exploration of future adjacencies aligned to personal growth?

5. Continuous Monitoring

Regular network health checks enable quick adaptation of ONA systems to emerging value-creation opportunities amidst dynamic reprioritization. But who decides the evolution path as trade-offs get evaluated between short-term returns versus long-term resilience? How might we balance efficiency gains with maintaining the diversity of perspectives that uplifts collective wisdom?

6. Feedback Loop

Embedding collaborative channels allows user experiences to shape ongoing solution upgrades revealed through usage metrics and experience surveys. But indeed, closing gaps means hearing whispers, not just loud voices. Does our process intentionally incorporate informal signals from the edges or remain constrained by closed ecosystems?

4 Strategic Moves for ONA Integration

Realizing ONA’s promise to upgrade performance management requires more than running advanced analytics. Like intricate clocks, the gears of strategy, culture, and technology must interlock toward shared objectives for the apparatus to reflect reality accurately. Where should organizations impatient for change but apprehensive of risks first direct energy?

  1. Commence by convening cross-functional teams to scoop current evaluation pain points and future possibilities. Highlight gaps between analog processes misaligned with digital workflows to build consensus on modernization needs from multiple lenses. Partner with people analytics specialists early to test planned interventions using pilot data. 

  1. Gather employee volunteers who are keen to bring ONA learnings into performance conversations and augmentation rather than automating manager responsibilities. Address skepticism through transparency on tracked metrics, consent policies, and usage guardrails to nurture trust in data collection. 

  1. With foundations anchored around inclusive adoption, prioritize platform reliability and access. Replace patchwork tools with a connected ecosystem guided by a user experience that moves technology from being the limitation to the liberator of potential. 

  1. Integrate ONA philosophers - specialized data translators adept at converting analytics into insights using storytelling - across business and function teams. Create rotational programs allowing more democratized exposure to humanized intelligence that informs rather than overwhelms decision-makers at all levels.

In closing, well-planned change management, stakeholder readiness, and modular technology development are indispensable to smooth ONA assimilation. But culture transformation must remain the guiding light – using disruption to direct organizations, leaders, and employees toward deeper connections, insight, and collective achievement. Does this strike the right balance between strategic and cultural considerations in ONA adoption?

Your ONA Action Plan

1. Appoint Dedicated ONA Teams

Assign full-time resources spanning HRBPs, IT architects, and analytics leads to drive swift coordination essential in transition phases. 

  • Example: A large bank created a centralized ‘Network Insights Unit’ with data specialists and consultants supporting business units.

2. Launch Interactive Training Modules  

Combine immersive simulated scenarios, microlearning apps, and two-way mentoring discussions to propagate ONA literacy enterprise-wide. 

  • Example: A technology company deployed a gaming simulation that allowed employees to practice using ONA dashboards to solve challenges.

3. Incentivize Use Case Innovation

Encourage teams to creatively apply ONA insights to enhance existing workflows through hackathons, awards, and leadership attention. 

  • Example: An FMCG company offered a development fund to cross-functional pitches using ONA to advance corporate priorities.  

4. Co-Create Practical Integration Blueprints  

Conduct participative prototype sprints, allowing user perspectives to shape the technical integration of ONA with surrounding HR systems. 

  • Example: A retailer co-designed wireframes of Johnson analytics visible within manager communication platforms to boost adoption.

5. Develop Risk-benefit Evaluation Frameworks

Construct quantifiable models balancing implementation costs, adoption uncertainty, and projected ROI based on capability maturity assessments. 

  • Example: A construction firm integrated ONA readiness diagnostics within IT risk assurance and compliance processes.

6. Maintain Continuous Stakeholder Communications

Share progress updates, address queries, and gather feedback through multi-channel outreach campaigns sustained post-deployment. 

  • Example: An automotive company sends bi-monthly newsletters to all employees highlighting ONA use cases and inviting ideas.


Key Insights

  • Transformative Impact of ONA: ONA's talent strategy now shifts from controlling individuals to empowering interactions, focusing on interconnected ecosystems beyond biased boxes. It promises to unlock potential, amplify marginalized voices, and rehumanize workplaces.

  • Need for a Holistic Approach: Upgrading culture requires balancing analytics with empathy, efficiency with inclusion, and management with mentorship. How can you adopt ONA's insights holistically, prioritizing ethics?

  • Continuous Evolution and Adaptation: To move forward, we must constantly broaden our understanding of how we create value to improve overall well-being. Regularly check-in, gather feedback, and adjust our recruiting processes, reward systems, and development programs. Doing so can build a sustainable approach to nurturing talent, even in uncertain times. However, achieving long-lasting equity requires more than just incremental improvements. It requires disruptive innovation grounded in universal human rights rather than simply meeting benchmarks.

Are Biased Reviews Holding Your Team Back?

Do "hidden figure" collaborators go unseen while vocal lone wolves get rewards?  

ONA mapping transcends limitations through data-backed insights, amplifying marginalized voices and guiding leaders to nurture modern capabilities. Learn more about how Confirm's interaction metrics make visible collective impact missing from reviews. See ONA in Action and reveal your blindspots!

A slide with the title "SEE ONA IN ACTION" at the top center and the logo of Confirm at the left bottom. Below the title is a text: "Confirm is the all-in-one people platform that creates a true reflection of each employee's impact and influence. Gounded in the science of Organizational Network Analysis (ONA), Confirm unveils who's actually driving impact in your organization.  and the text
Click on the image to visit Confirm and see ONA in action.

We are powering the future of HR!

Hacking HR is the fastest-growing global community of people leaders and professionals interested in all things at the intersection of people, organizations, innovation, transformation, workplace and workforce, and more. We deliver value through hundreds of events a year, community engagement opportunities, learning programs, (soon) our certificate programs, and more. Join our community platform, the Hacking HR LAB. Click here

0

Document Map

Get more content like this in your Inbox

Email is required

Subscribe

Share the Article

on every platform

Instagram
Tiktok

Related Posts